10 Critical Reasons Why Cats Shouldn’t Be Treated Like Dogs

Written By

Dr. Muqeet Mushtaq, DVM

Updated on

Dr. Muqeet Mushtaq, DVM

Cat and dog with owner
Petra Vajdova/Pexels

They both have paws, fur, and love a good nap, but cats and dogs couldn’t be more different when it comes to how they think, feel, and behave. Treating your cat like a dog might seem harmless—but it can actually lead to stress, confusion, and even health issues. Here are 10 critical reasons why your feline friend deserves a cat-appropriate approach.

1. Difference In Temperament

cat and dog
Helena Jankovičová Kováčová/Pexels

Cats and dogs have vastly different temperaments, and understanding these distinctions is crucial to forming a strong bond with each species. Dogs are typically social, eager to please, and thrive on interaction and companionship. They often look to their owners for guidance and approval. In contrast, cats are more independent and reserved, preferring to maintain control over their environment. While dogs might seek constant attention and affection, cats tend to show love on their own terms, enjoying solitude and quiet moments more than continuous interaction. This difference in temperament is key to how we approach their care and training.

2. Exercise Requirements

dog getting professional training
Blue Bird/Pexels

Cats have different exercise needs compared to dogs, which makes treating them the same a mistake. While dogs often need daily walks and outdoor time to burn off energy, cats are generally more self-sufficient in this regard. Most cats are content with indoor play, whether it’s chasing a toy or pouncing on a laser dot. They may not require the same level of structured exercise, and forcing them to go for walks or run on a leash can lead to stress or anxiety. Respecting their more independent approach ensures a healthier and happier pet.

3. Bonding With Owners

Cat and dog
Anna Tarazevich/Pexels

Bonding with cats requires patience and respect for their independent nature. Unlike dogs, who often seek constant attention and affection, cats tend to form connections on their own terms. They may not greet you enthusiastically at the door or follow you everywhere, but their bond is often more subtle. Cats show affection through quiet gestures, like sitting on your lap, purring, or following you around the house when they feel comfortable. Understanding these signals and respecting their boundaries will foster a deeper, more meaningful relationship with your cat.

4. Prey Drive

Cat preying on birds
Tuğba/Pexels

Cats have a strong prey drive, an instinctive behavior rooted in their wild ancestors. Unlike dogs, who are often socialized for specific roles, cats are natural hunters, constantly observing and stalking their surroundings. This instinct is triggered by movement, and even simple toys can spark their desire to pounce. Trying to treat them like dogs, with constant interaction or over-structured routines, overlooks their need for independent exploration and hunting-like behavior, which is essential for their well-being and mental stimulation.

5. Diet Requirements

dog eating
cottonbro/Pexels

Cats have very specific dietary needs that differ significantly from dogs. As obligate carnivores, they require a diet high in animal protein to thrive, whereas dogs are omnivores and can handle a more varied diet. Cats need certain nutrients, like taurine, arachidonic acid, and vitamin A, which they can only get from animal-based sources. Providing a cat with dog food, or a dog with cat food, can result in nutritional deficiencies and other health complications. Understanding and catering to these dietary differences is essential for a cat’s well-being.

6. Vocalization Level

Dog barking
SplitShire/Pexels

Cats are generally much quieter than dogs, using meows, purrs, and occasional growls only for specific communication, like requesting food or expressing contentment. Unlike dogs, who often bark for attention or to alert you to something, cats don’t rely on vocalization for constant interaction. Expecting cats to behave like dogs in this regard can lead to frustration, as they prefer a more reserved approach to communication. Embracing their quieter nature allows for a deeper understanding of their personality and strengthens the bond between owner and pet.

7. Veterinary Requirements

Dog At Vet Clinic
freepik/Freepik

Cats have specific veterinary requirements that differ from those of dogs, and treating them the same can be problematic. For instance, cats are more sensitive to certain medications that are safe for dogs, and some treatments that work for dogs may not be effective or even safe for cats. Cats have specific veterinary requirements that differ from those of dogs, such as more sensitivity to certain medications, and different vaccination and dental schedules. Regular veterinary visits tailored to their unique health needs are vital to keeping them healthy, something that should not be ignored.

8. Grooming Requirements

cat grooming
Reba Spike/Unsplash

Cats have unique grooming needs that set them apart from dogs. While dogs may require regular baths and consistent grooming, cats are natural self-groomers. Most cats will spend hours grooming themselves to stay clean, using their rough tongues to remove dirt and loose fur. However, some long-haired breeds may need occasional brushing to prevent matting. Unlike dogs, cats generally don’t need frequent baths unless absolutely necessary, making their grooming routine much more independent and low-maintenance. Understanding this difference is crucial to keeping your cat healthy and comfortable.

9. Playing Style

Dog fetching toy while swimming
Blue Bird/Pexels

Cats and dogs have vastly different playing styles, which is crucial to understand when caring for them. Dogs tend to be more energetic and interactive, enjoying games like fetch or tug-of-war, which often involve direct interaction with their owners. In contrast, cats generally prefer to play by themselves or with interactive toys that mimic prey, like feather wands or laser pointers. Their play is usually more stealthy and calculated, reflecting their natural hunting instincts. Understanding these differences ensures both pets’ mental and physical stimulation needs are met appropriately.

10. Trainability

Training a German shepherd dog
gustavo fring/Pexels

Cats have a much different approach to training compared to dogs, making their trainability more challenging. While dogs are eager to please and often respond well to commands, cats are more independent and less motivated by external rewards. They may learn a few tricks, but training sessions are often on their own terms. Their self-sufficient nature means they prefer to explore or play when they want, rather than following structured routines. This independent streak can make training cats a slower, less predictable process.

Love Pets as Much as We Do?

General follow
dikaya37/123rf

Scroll up and click the ‘Follow’ button to stay updated with the latest heart-warming, hilarious, and helpful pet posts from Pawdown, delivered straight to your Microsoft Start feed and MSN homepage!

Related Posts

Discover 6 science-backed reasons canine massage improves pain relief, mobility, recovery, anxiety, circulation, and early detection.
Shinier fur starts from within! These 12 vet-approved diet tweaks can help transform your dog’s coat from dull to dazzling.
Discover 8 energetic Australian dog breeds that thrive on activity, challenge, and purpose—perfect for active homes.
Meet 8 lovable dog breeds often called “too jumpy” around kids—and learn what fuels their playful, over-the-top energy.
Meet the fearless dogs that face every challenge with unwavering courage—guardians, warriors, and loyal companions like no other.
Meet the newly discovered Andean mountain cat—an elusive high-altitude feline that's rewriting science and inspiring conservation worldwide.
Discover 15 captivating cat breeds born in the USA—each with a unique origin, striking look, and heartwarming personality.
Turn fear into trust with simple gestures that help your shelter dog feel safe, loved, and finally home—where they truly belong.
Even seasoned cat owners can slip up. Discover 15 common cat-care mistakes and how to avoid them—your feline deserves better.