10 Predator Fish That You Can Legally Keep in Your Fish Tank in America

Written By

Mathew Abraham

Updated on

Mathew Abraham

Meet Mathew, Cat Dad and Animal Advocate! Mathew is the editor at PawDown, overseeing content strategy and quality. He's in charge of carefully curating the best pet stories, tips, and advice for you.

angelfish inside an aquarium
Josephina Kolpachnikof/Unsplash

Creating an aquarium filled with predatory fish can be an exciting challenge for aquarists looking to break away from traditional community tanks. While some predator fish grow too large for home aquariums, there are smaller species that can thrive in a well-maintained setup. However, keeping predatory fish requires careful planning regarding tank size, compatible tankmates, and dietary needs. Let’s explore ten predator fish that are both legal and suitable for home aquariums, offering a thrilling experience for dedicated fish keepers.

1. Bucktooth Tetra

Bucktooth tetra Fish
J_90_/Reddit

The Bucktooth Tetra is a striking and aggressive fish known for its shimmering silver body adorned with red and yellow hues. Unlike most tetras, this species is carnivorous and has a peculiar habit of nipping scales off other fish, making them unsuitable for community tanks. They thrive in groups of at least 12 to prevent intraspecies aggression. These fast-moving hunters prefer a well-planted tank with open swimming space. At around 4 to 6 inches long, they require a minimum 55-gallon tank. Feeding includes live, frozen, or high-protein pellets. Their energetic nature and bold personalities make them an intriguing choice for advanced aquarists.

2. Dwarf Pike Cichlid (Crenicichla regani)

Dwarf Pike Cichlid
visionist/Reddit

The Dwarf Pike Cichlid is a smaller relative of the larger, more aggressive pike cichlids. Reaching up to 6 inches, they have elongated bodies and exhibit vibrant green and brown markings. They are known for their territorial nature but can be kept with similar-sized tankmates if provided with enough hiding spots. These predatory cichlids enjoy hunting small invertebrates and fish, so tank companions should be chosen wisely. They require at least a 40-gallon tank with caves and driftwood. Feeding consists of live or frozen foods, making them a rewarding yet demanding species for experienced keepers.

3. Leaf Fish (Monocirrhus polyacanthus)

South American Leaf Fish
STTUTM/Reddit

The Leaf Fish is a master of disguise, resembling a floating leaf to ambush prey. Native to slow-moving waters in South America, these fish grow up to 4 inches and require a densely planted aquarium to thrive. They are ambush predators that feed on small live fish, making them unsuitable for typical community setups. Due to their sedentary nature, a 30-gallon tank is sufficient. They require excellent water quality and a diet consisting of small feeder fish or invertebrates. Their cryptic appearance and unique hunting strategy make them an exciting choice for those fascinated by stealthy predators.

4. African Butterfly Fish (Pantodon buchholzi)

African butterfly fish
ToxicAbuse/Reddit

The African Butterfly Fish is a surface-dwelling predator known for its wing-like fins and ability to leap out of the water. They grow up to 5 inches and require a tank with a secure lid to prevent escape. Preferring calm waters, they thrive in heavily planted tanks with floating vegetation. They primarily feed on live insects and small fish, but can adapt to frozen foods. Their aggressive nature means they should not be kept with small tankmates. A minimum tank size of 30 gallons is recommended. Watching them hunt and glide across the water surface is a captivating experience for aquarists.

5. Rainbow Snakehead (Channa bleheri)

Rainbow Snakehead (Channa Bleheri)
hokkaidojan/Reddit

The Rainbow Snakehead is a compact yet vibrant predator, reaching up to 20 cm in length. Native to Upper Assam, India, it features a cigar-shaped body with vivid orange and blue hues, tiger-patterned ventral fins, and a blue dorsal fin edged in orange. This species thrives in well-lit aquariums with hard, alkaline water and ample swimming space. Though usually kept alone due to its predatory nature, it may coexist with large, robust fish like Botias and Barbs. It breathes atmospheric oxygen using a labyrinth organ, making it highly adaptable to varied water conditions.

6. Angelfish (Pterophyllum scalare)

Angelfish
Fahad AlAni_Pexels

Despite their elegant appearance, Angelfish are predatory cichlids that can be aggressive towards smaller tankmates. Growing up to 6 inches, they have long, flowing fins and striking patterns. They thrive in a well-planted tank with plenty of vertical swimming space. Angelfish prefer live or frozen foods such as bloodworms and brine shrimp but can also eat high-protein pellets. They are best kept with similarly sized fish to prevent them from preying on smaller species. A minimum tank size of 30 gallons is recommended, and their territorial nature becomes more pronounced during breeding.

7. Leopard Bush Fish (Ctenopoma acutirostre)

Rainbow Snakehead (Channa Bleheri)
hokkaidojan/Reddit

The Leopard Bush Fish, also known as the African Leaf Fish, is a slow-moving ambush predator with an intricately patterned body that helps it blend into its environment. Reaching up to 6 inches, they require a heavily planted aquarium with plenty of hiding spaces. These nocturnal hunters feed on live fish, shrimp, and insects but can be trained to eat frozen foods. They are relatively peaceful when not hunting, making them suitable for larger community tanks with non-aggressive tankmates. A 40-gallon tank is ideal, and they offer an intriguing look into nature’s stealthy hunting techniques.

8. Bichir (Polypterus senegalus)

Senegal Bichir
OphanimWheels/Reddit

The Senegal Bichir, also called the Dinosaur Eel, is a fascinating bottom-dwelling predator. Growing up to 12 inches, they require a tank of at least 75 gallons. With their prehistoric appearance and lung-like swim bladders, they frequently surface to breathe air. These nocturnal hunters feed on meaty foods, including shrimp, fish fillets, and pellets. While they are generally peaceful, they will eat any fish small enough to fit in their mouths. Their hardy nature and unique behaviors make them a great choice for those looking to keep a primitive yet manageable predator fish.

9. Jack Dempsey (Rocio octofasciata)

Jack Dempsey (Rocio octofasciata)
HenryC88, Own work, CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons

The Jack Dempsey is a striking and aggressive cichlid known for its iridescent blue, green, and purple scales. Growing up to 10 inches, they require a minimum 55-gallon tank with hiding spots to reduce aggression. They are territorial and will prey on smaller fish, so tankmates should be of similar size and temperament. They thrive on a diet of high-protein pellets, live, or frozen foods. Their bold personalities and interactive nature make them an excellent choice for aquarists who want an engaging predatory fish with striking colors.

10. Red Tail Shark (Epalzeorhynchos bicolor)

Red Tail Shark (Epalzeorhynchos bicolor)
magnoliasmanor/Reddit

The Red Tail Shark is a semi-aggressive predator with a sleek black body and a vibrant red tail. Growing up to 6 inches, they require a minimum 50-gallon tank with caves and hiding spots to establish territories. These territorial fish should be kept alone or with fast-moving tankmates to minimize aggression. They are omnivorous but prefer high-protein foods like bloodworms, shrimp, and sinking pellets. Their energetic nature and striking appearance make them a favorite among experienced aquarists looking for active yet manageable predator fish.

Love Pets as Much as We Do?

General follow
dikaya37/123rf

Scroll up and click the ‘Follow’ button to stay updated with the latest heart-warming, hilarious, and helpful pet posts from Pawdown, delivered straight to your Microsoft Start feed and MSN homepage!

Related Posts

Sharks in New York? Discover 8 fascinating species roaming the state's coastal waters—some harmless, others powerful.
Discover 5 small fish species that do well in nano tanks and 3 you should absolutely avoid. Learn what makes them thrive—or fail—in compact aquatic setups.
Explore 7 stunning saltwater fish species legal to own in the U.S., each requiring expert care and specific tank conditions to thrive.
Explore 10 peaceful fish perfect for community tanks—plus 5 aggressive ones you should think twice about before adding.
From koi to discus, these long-lived species thrive with the right environment, diet, and maintenance. Here are 12 fish that can exceed 10 years with dedicated care.
Turn your tank into a mesmerizing masterpiece with these rare and unique fish that captivate with their beauty, rarity, and charm.
Hidden dangers like poor water quality, overfeeding, and stress could be killing your aquarium fish. Learn how to keep them safe!
Discover 10 nano fish that thrive in small tanks and 5 large fish species that fascinate aquarists of all levels. Find the right fish for your space and style.
Discover 7 ideal tankmates for goldfish—from hillstream loaches to ricefish—that bring harmony, color, and balance to your aquarium.