Hermit crabs are the kind of pet that seem simple at first—but surprise, they’ve got a whole list of quirks. They don’t need daily walks or constant attention, which makes them seem perfect for chill folks or first-time pet owners. But before you bring one home, you should know they’re not just a shell with legs. Like any pet, they come with both perks and headaches. Whether you’re into low-key companions or just love weird little creatures, here’s the real deal on owning a hermit crab.
1. Pro: Low-Maintenance Lifestyle
One of the biggest pros is how easygoing hermit crabs are. You don’t need to walk them, bathe them, or entertain them constantly. Feed them every other day, keep their tank clean, and they’re golden. Because they’re so low-effort, they fit well into a busy or forgetful person’s lifestyle. Plus, they’re independent and don’t crave attention. However, “low maintenance” doesn’t mean no care at all—you still need to watch humidity, temperature, and diet. But compared to dogs or even hamsters, hermit crabs are super chill companions.
2. Con: Not Super Cuddly
If you’re hoping for cuddles or affection, hermit crabs might disappoint you. They’re not the kind of pet that seeks you out or bonds deeply. In fact, they might just hide all day or get stressed when handled. Because of this, they’re better for people who enjoy watching animals rather than interacting with them. While they’re fascinating to observe, they don’t offer much in the way of emotional connection. So if you want a pet that loves you back—maybe stick to dogs, cats, or even rats.
3. Pro: They Live A Surprisingly Long Time
Surprise! Hermit crabs aren’t short-term pets. With proper care, they can live over a decade—and some have even made it past 30. Because of this, you’re not just getting a temporary desk buddy; you’re signing up for a long-term commitment. That can be awesome if you want a stable companion who sticks around. However, it also means you’ll need to maintain their habitat for years. Still, for people who love routine and long-haul relationships (even with crustaceans), this longevity is definitely a big win.
4. Con: They Need More Than A Shell And Sand
A lot of people think hermit crabs just need a shell, sand, and some food—but nope. Their habitat actually has to mimic a tropical environment with the right humidity, temperature, substrate, climbing areas, and both fresh and saltwater. Because they rely on that environment to survive, a cheap plastic cage won’t cut it. And if the tank isn’t set up right, they can get sick or die. So while they’re low-maintenance in some ways, their setup definitely requires more effort (and money) than most expect.
5. Pro: Super Fun To Watch
Hermit crabs are lowkey hilarious when you take time to watch them. They climb, dig, bicker over shells, and sometimes even change outfits (aka shells) mid-drama. Because they’re most active at night, they make great late-night entertainment without being noisy or destructive. It’s almost like watching a crab version of a soap opera. Plus, setting up their tank with fun accessories gives you a way to customize their world. If you’re into low-key, background weirdness with random surprises, they’ll definitely keep you amused.
6. Con: Molting Is Kinda Gross (And Stressful)
Molting is when hermit crabs shed their exoskeleton to grow—but it’s a stressful and strange process. They’ll bury themselves for days, sometimes weeks, and you might think they’ve died. Because they’re so vulnerable during this time, you can’t disturb them at all. Other crabs might even attack them if housed together. It’s gross, tense, and unpredictable. While molting is natural and necessary, it can be hard to handle as an owner. So if you’re squeamish or get anxious easily, this part might freak you out.
7. Pro: They Don’t Smell (If You Clean Their Tank)
One major perk: hermit crabs don’t smell or make noise—if you keep their tank clean. There’s no barking, squeaking, shedding, or litter box stench. Because of that, they’re ideal for apartments, dorms, or shared spaces. Just clean up old food and waste, and you’ll barely notice a smell. Even when they’re active, the most they’ll do is scratch around at night. So if you’re sensitive to noise or odors—or you’ve got roommates who are—you’ll definitely appreciate how low-impact these little guys are.
8. Con: They’re Social—So You’ll Need More Than One
Hermit crabs are surprisingly social, and keeping one alone isn’t great for their mental health. In the wild, they live in big groups—so they get lonely without crabby friends. Because of that, you’ll need at least two or three, which means a bigger tank, more shells, more food, and more cleanup. Plus, crab drama is real. They’ll sometimes fight over shells or space. So while buying one crab sounds simple, it usually means you’re accidentally committing to a whole little crab squad.
9. Pro: They’re Quiet And Chill
If you’ve got strict lease rules or grumpy roommates, hermit crabs are the ultimate peacekeepers. They’re silent, smell-free, and don’t take up much space. Because they’re so chill and self-contained, most landlords don’t even count them as “real” pets. They won’t chew wires, scratch furniture, or bark at the mailman. Plus, they stay in their tank, so there’s zero risk of unexpected crab escapes—unless your lid sucks. For people in small spaces or shared living situations, they’re pretty much the least annoying pet you could have.
10. Con: Hard To Find Good Info And Supplies
One of the trickiest parts of hermit crab ownership? Figuring out the truth. Pet stores often give outdated or flat-out wrong advice, like tiny tanks, dry environments, or unsafe painted shells. Because of that, new owners accidentally mess things up. Also, supplies like proper substrate, sea salt, or extra shells aren’t always easy to find locally. So you’ll probably end up ordering stuff online and spending time in niche crab forums. If you’re not into doing some extra research, this part might frustrate you.
Love Pets as Much as We Do?
Scroll up and click the ‘Follow’ button to stay updated with the latest heartwarming, hilarious, and helpful pet posts from Pawdown, delivered straight to your Microsoft Start feed and MSN homepage!