Gar fish are fascinating creatures that have been around for millions of years, with fossil records dating back to the Cretaceous period. Their primitive features and resilience make them intriguing but also challenging to keep in home aquariums. While their sleek, torpedo-like bodies and prehistoric appearance might tempt some fishkeepers, these fish are not ideal for the average home tank. Here’s why keeping a gar fish is more trouble than you might think.
1. The Ancient Predator – Too Big for Most Tanks
Gar fish, particularly the alligator gar, can grow up to 10 feet long in the wild. Even the smaller species, like the spotted gar, can reach up to 3 feet. A standard home aquarium, even a large one, is simply not big enough to accommodate their needs. Unlike other fish that can adjust to tank size, gar fish continue growing and can quickly outgrow even a spacious setup. If you don’t have a tank that’s at least several hundred gallons, keeping a gar is unrealistic and could lead to stunted growth and health issues.
2. Voracious Eaters – Not for Community Tanks
Gars are natural-born hunters with a serious appetite for live prey. Their diet consists mainly of fish, crustaceans, and sometimes even small mammals in the wild. If you think they’ll coexist peacefully with your other aquarium fish, think again. Gars are ambush predators that strike quickly and will view anything small enough as food. Unless you want to keep them in a tank by themselves and supply them with a constant stream of live food, they are not the best choice for a community aquarium.
3. Jumping Masters – Escape Artists Extraordinaire
Gar fish are known to be excellent jumpers. In the wild, they often leap out of the water to catch prey or escape predators. In an aquarium setting, this means they are likely to attempt jumping out of the tank, which can lead to injury or even death. A tightly secured, heavy lid is a must, but even then, their sheer strength can cause damage to tank covers. If you’re not prepared to deal with constant escape attempts, a gar fish might not be the right pet for you.
4. Filtration Nightmare – They Mess Up the Water Quickly
Gars are large, messy eaters that produce a significant amount of waste. They require a highly efficient filtration system to keep water conditions stable. Without powerful filtration, ammonia and nitrate levels can quickly spike, creating a toxic environment that can be harmful to both the gar and any other fish in the tank. Regular water changes and top-tier filtration are non-negotiable, making their upkeep much more demanding than that of typical aquarium fish.
5. Not a Friendly Pet – Little to No Interaction
If you’re looking for a fish that recognizes you and interacts, gar fish will leave you disappointed. Unlike other large fish, like oscars, which develop a bond with their owners, gars remain indifferent. They don’t beg for food, show excitement when you’re around, or interact in any meaningful way. They are more like living fossils—fascinating to watch but not engaging as pets. If you want a fish with personality, a gar isn’t the best choice.
6. Legal Issues – Restricted in Many Areas
Many regions have strict regulations against keeping gar fish, especially species like the alligator gar, due to their potential impact on local ecosystems. In some places, it is illegal to own one without a special permit. Before even considering bringing one home, you need to check local laws. The last thing you want is to invest in a large setup only to find out that keeping a gar fish in your area is prohibited.
Love Pets as Much as We Do?
Scroll up and click the ‘Follow’ button to stay updated with the latest heart-warming, hilarious, and helpful pet posts from Pawdown, delivered straight to your Microsoft Start feed and MSN homepage!
